carrying food home in winter margaret atwood analysis

In an attempt to focus on Canadian experiences, Atwood has populated her stories with Canadian cities, conflicts, and contemporary people. Although the majority of the text is devoted to Homer, there are many references to Atwood as well as comparisons to Lewis Carroll. Atwood, Margaret, The Edible Woman, First published 1969. Marcia knows she will cry on Christmas Day, because life, however horrific at times, rushes by, and she is helpless to stop it: Its all this hope. Atwood begins the story with a first-person narrator, Marian McAlpin, telling the story from her own perspective, almost sounding as if she were talking to herself. eNotes.com, Inc. Women should be allowed, Friedan observed, to have the same freedom as men. 3, Sept. 1995, pp. Frank N. Magill. Does Fish's theory regarding the psychosexual meaning of Alice in Wonderland seem plausible? CARRYING FOOD HOME IN WINTER - poem - YouTube Margaret Atwood's poem Carrying Food Home in Winter Margaret Atwood's poem Carrying Food Home in Winter. This was a time prior to the revitalization of the women's movement, a time when women were expected to marry and upon that marriage to quit their jobs, if they had them, and stay home and have children. An extensive bibliography is included. Beginning as an aversion to eggs (an obvious fertility symbol) and to meat (the trophy of the hunter), the block is eventually generalized to other foods and culminates in her not eating at all, even though the majority of scenes are set in restaurants or kitchens and much of the action involves ingestion. How do you assess the circumstances in which Marian finds herself at the novel's outset? Correspondingly, Atwood switches back to a first-person narration. As the noise level of the party escalates, Mrs. Nolan calls the police but cannot wait for them to arrive. Toronto: Harper- Flamingo Canada, 1998. Word Count: 267. 12. On one level the novel functions as an entertaining comedy of manners in its juxtaposition of widely divergent communities in a rapidly changing Toronto, including upwardly-mobile young singles, would-be intelligentsia, and aggressively conventional middle- class families. On the one hand, the prospect of colder days rouses our instinctive survival fears, but on the other, sanitised modern winters offer both a sensory and emotional allurecrackling fires, fuzzy jumpers, hot drinks and festive family celebrations are routinely fetishised. Goldblatt continues, "these women . Vol. Contact us for pricing and an estimate for your special event! Supply Chain Management; Banking, Financial Services . 8 vols. The second thing you might notice is that there are now portable toilets in the corner of the parking area, near the main trailhead. Sandler, Linda, in Catherine McLays The Dark Voyage: The Edible Woman as Romance, The Art of Margaret Atwood: Essays in Criticism, Arnold E. Davidson and Cathy N. Davidson, eds. Bloom, Harold, ed. 3527, October 2, 1969, p. 1122. It is their major responsibility to buy and cook food. Cooke, Nathalie. Carrying Food Home in Winter by Margaret Atwood | Poetry Magazine April 1969 | Jon Anderson, John Ashbery, Margaret Atwood, Edward Brash, Jim Carroll, Glover Davis, Sheldon Flory, Robert Hass, William Heyen, David Martin, Nancy Sullivan, John Tagliabue, James Tate, Richard Tillinghast, Laurence Lieberman Added about 2 months ago by d 1 May 2023 , Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Word Count: 295. Family Meals Serve (approximately) 4 People. It was during this time that the feminist movement, also referred to as the Women's Liberation Movement, experienced a renaissance in both countries. Gale Cengage Section 1 employs first-person, though unreliable, narration, in section 2 the narrator refers to herself in third person as she essentially loses touch with who she is, and the third section returns to first person as the narrator reclaims her identity. Deutsch, Andre, Review, in Times Literary Supplement, No. Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts. After all, theres a reason such a facility is sometimes politely called the necessary house.". I would. Ed. Call or email to check availability and to receive an estimate. Beginning with the title of the book and journeying through the final chapters, someone or something is either being described in terms of food, or is being eaten. Special Collections and University Archives. Atwood employs a trite but effective conceit as, at Marians moment of acceptance, lightning flashes, permanently etching her reflection in his eyes. 2001 eNotes.com As Scottish poet Andrew Young wrote in Last Snow, One green spear/Stabbing a dead leaf from below/Kills winter at a blowthe annual life-affirming triumph of life over death, love over loneliness. Yet even the focus on food is important, as . Virtually all the pieces focus on the lives of women equivocally connected to the men around them. Copyright 2023 Carriage House Catering - All Rights Reserved. One of Margaret Atwoods (born November 18, 1939) central themes is storytelling itself, and most of her fiction relates to that theme in some way. Yet I Speak, Yet I Exist: Affirmation of the Subject in Atwoods Short Stories. In Margaret Atwood: Writing and Subjectivity, edited by Colin Nelson. Dodson, Danita J., "An Interview with Margaret Atwood," in Critique: Studies in Contemporary Fiction, Vol. Ed. https://www.thefreedictionary.com/carrying+out, She begged to be allowed to accompany him, but he insisted that it might result in the man's, Dictionary, Encyclopedia and Thesaurus - The Free Dictionary, the webmaster's page for free fun content. Sometimes he would whistle, sometimes. Carrington, Ildiko de Papp, Margaret Atwood and Her Works, Toronto: ECW Press, 1985. Get food delivery from local favorite restaurants and caterers near you. Examine The Edible Woman as a female bildungsroman. Atwoods stories are frequently explorations of human limitation, presentations of people as victims of history, biology, or cultural conditioning. Copyright 2023 Carriage House Catering - All Rights Reserved. Sign up to hear from us about specials, sales, and events. Hikers arriving at immensely popular Mount Major in Alton this summer will find a few changes, as the Forest Society is working with our partners to improve the experience little by little. Poetry, v.114: 1 April, 1969, 0561, item: 0561. A frequent theme in Atwoods fiction and poetry is the power struggle between men and women. Not affiliated with Harvard College. The female identity crisis Marian suffers reflects the cultural assumptions of a society that not only dictates traditional roles but also replaces individuality with plastic inauthenticity; no one can achieve real identity in the deadening atmosphere of such technocratic societies. Word Count: 247. 2948. Word Count: 57. Margaret Atwood was born in 1939 in Ottawa and grew up in northern Ontario, Quebec, and Toronto. No one wants to carry you out once youve carried yourself in. Everybody hikes Mount Major, but nobody likes a trail lined with dog waste. Finally, it is too much. Struggling against the patriarchy, or male-dominated society, and the roles that society imposes on women, the female characters in The Edible Woman each deal with the cultural attitude in their own way, each coming to different conclusions, each taking different paths. 10. Ed. "The Edible Woman - Literary Precedents" Beacham's Encyclopedia of Popular Fiction 11 (Summer, 1978), pp. 53, October 3, 1970, p. 40. The short-story collections each focus on key issues. It is difficult to find appropriate words to define Margaret Atwood's (born November 18, 1939) significance in Canadian culture and literature. . Admission Process; Fee Structure; Scholarship; Loans and Financial aid; Programs. date the date you are citing the material. Hours, Special Collections in Performing Arts 1993: The Canadian federal government sets up a panel on violence against women. When it comes to showing said traditions, "The Painted Door" and "Travel Piece" shows the traits "Survival" describes, but they manage to execute them in their own unique way. 73-82. Patton prefers to look at Atwood's stories in terms of politics. Analysis. Download the entire The Edible Woman study guide as a printable PDF! Log in here. Gale Cengage Atwood, Margaret, "Margaret Atwood, Writing Philosophy," Waterstone's Poetry Lecture Series delivered at Hay On Wye, Wales, June 1995, taken from "Canadian Poets" on the Canadian Poetry website, University of Toronto, 2000, www.library.utoronto.ca/canpoetry (last accessed March, 2001). In good company we can enjoy winters hostile beauty. carrying out: See: act , action , commission , enforcement , performance Easton, Elizabeth, Review, in Saturday Review, Vol. 1 May 2023 , Last Updated on June 1, 2019, by eNotes Editorial. In Dancing Girls, a gift for comic and satiric invention is evident from the first story, The Man from Mars. Christine, an unattractive undergraduate at a Canadian university, is literally pursued by an odd-looking, desperately poor exchange student. Sep 1, 2020 - April 1960 | Robert Bly, Philip Booth, Turner Cassity, Joanne De Longchamps, David Galler, Daniel Hoffman, Edwin Honig, Kenneth Koch, Maxine Kumin . And to whom is it given? feminists of the 1960s concluded that the whole of society is pervaded by a sexism that relegates all women to a subservient role. Good Bones and Simple Murders incorporates some material from Murder in the Dark. Deery, June. 6. She graduates and settles into a drab government job and a sterile existence. Ed. Atwood has called this an "anti-comedy," working against the conventions of romance since no couple is formed at the end. Females, in the cultural context of this story, control food. Make a lasting impression with the freshest and current ideas in cuisine, design, and presentation. An editor At the storys end, he is staring into the chill, uninhabitable interior of Canadas far north, a perfect metaphor for the coldness of the human heart that the story has revealed and an ironic reversal of the storys epigraph, with its hopeful reference to humans who somehow have won from space/ This unchill, habitable interior. The polarities between Louises initial vision of a warmly enclosing circle of friends and Morrisons final bleak vision of what poet William Butler Yeats called the desolation of reality seem irreconcilable in this story. Carrying Food Home in Winter by Margaret Atwood on her birthday. California: Do Not Sell My Personal Information, An American musical about mental health takes off in China. Giving Birth is about a physical process, but it is also about language and the relationship between fiction and reality. Margaret Atwood. Yet when the narrator becomes a mother herself, she gains a new perspective and this moment altered for me. What finally emerges between mother and narrator-daughter is not communication but growing estrangement. They have traveled, bringing back a sundial from England and a domestic servant from theWest Indies. Avant, John Alfred, Review, in Library Journal, Vol. Finally, he discovers that he loves Louise, but only because she is by now truly crazy, defenseless, drugged into manageability.. One of the most obvious style techniques that Atwood uses in The Edible Woman is her unusual use of point of view, or the perspective from which the story is told. Corpse-"Corpse Song" The corpse depicts unalterable mortality for it is trapped in a world devoid of an exit. Atwood's fondness for intertextual dialogue between her own work and that of a precursor fiction surfaces here in the inclusion of a lengthy discussion of Alice in Wonderland offered by Duncan's graduate student friend Fish. For Further Study The boring rhythm of . Suarez, Isabel Carrera. I walk uphill through the snow hard going brown paper bags of groceries balanced low on my stomach, heavy, my arms stretching to hold it turn all tendon. The elements of science fiction are revealed when we read the story and find that someone is narrating a life experience on earth to someone from another planet, probably to an alien. Jun 26, 2016 - August 1916 | Joseph Campbell, Padraic Colum, Alice Henderson, Harriet Monroe, Anita Fitch, Ruth Hall, Amy Lowell, Clinton Masseck, John McCarthy, Jean The Question and Answer section for The Poems of Margaret Atwood is a great Pasadena, Calif.: Salem Press, 2004. Davey, Frank, An Unneeded Biography, Margaret Atwood: A Feminist Poetics, Vancouver: Talon Books, 1984. As Marian's wedding approaches, she begins to feel that Peter is consuming her. Rosenberg, Jerome H. Margaret Atwood. Whether it's breakfast, a lucheon, or an evening party, we will help you impress your guests and clients at your next special event with delivery and full service catering that will surpass both yours and their expectations. Eating disorders, one expression of that fear, have become a familiar topic of conversation since the novel's publication, and will no doubt elicit considerable commentary. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Miscellaneous: The Tent, 2006. It is at this point, when Marian has reestablished her power within herself, that Peter is unable to eat the cake, and Marian eats it for him. Because the impending marriage also implies subsequent childbearing, Marian is surrounded by signs of fecundity; almost every female character in the novel is either already a mother, expecting a child, or plotting to become impregnated. You might think of it as crowdsourcing trash management, while avoiding having a smelly, overflowing trash bin that attracts vermin on the trail. It sets the scene for devotion, as seen in Margaret Atwood's "Carrying . Word Count: 768. The novel's wryly comic tone presents Marian's dilemma as the absurd consequence of a society with absurd preoccupations and habits. "The Edible Woman - Compare and Contrast" Novels for Students While Jeanie is taken to the labor room in a wheelchair, the other woman is rolled by on a table with her eyes closed and a tube in her arm: Something is wrong., In this story, Atwood suggests that such mysterious human ordeals as giving birth or dying can never be adequately prepared for or fully communicated through language: When there is no pain she feels nothing, when there is pain, she feels nothing because there is no she. The short-story collections each focus on key issues. https://archives.lib.umd.edu//repositories/2/archival_objects/485621 Accessed May 01, 2023. 1969: The House of Commons in Canada passes an Omnibus Bill covering birth control. With his phallocentrism evident in his explicitly Freudian approach to Carroll's text, Fish transforms the established interpretation of Alice as a girl suffering a sexual identity crisis into a more narrowly prescriptive cautionary tale of thwarted female maturation. This discussion of Atwood's novel The Handmaid's Tale explores her views on feminism, postcolonialism, and utopianism. Kelly, Darlene, "Either Way, I Stand Condemned," in English Studies in Canada, Vol. Canada's federal government set up the Royal Commission on the Status of Women in 1967 to examine women's role in society; three years later, the commission made 167 recommendations for greater equality for women. Family Meals Serve (approximately) 4 People. Christine also typifies supposedly enlightened, liberal attitudes, having been president of the United Nations Club in high school, and in college a member of the forensics team, debating such topics as the obsolescence of war. "The Edible Woman - Media Adaptations" Novels for Students 73-92. An effective, uniformly controlled collection of ten stories from the author of, most recently, Cat's Eye (1989). She is a dominating, manipulating woman (of the type seen also in The Resplendent Quetzal), and her relationship to her husband seems to be that of doting mother to overprotected child, despite the fact that he is a successful and respected cardiologist, and she has no meaningful identity outside her marriage. We know that every event is unique and special. Frank Northen Magill. bristles on the back of his neck. Whether walking the streets of 21st-century Manhattan or trekking the wild hills of 18th-century Scotland, the impulse is to protect the one you're with. Dave Carley wrote a play adapted from Margaret Atwood's novel The Edible Woman. "The Edible Woman - Historical Context" Novels for Students Jeanie diligently attends natural-childbirth classes and cheerfully anticipates the experience of birth and motherhood. Required to write a version of the Bluebeard fable, Sally decides to retell the story from the point of view of the egg, because it reminds her of Eds head, both so closed and unaware. Sally is shocked into a new assessment of Ed, however, when she witnesses a scene of sexual intimacy between her husband and her best friend. But it should also stir debate about the emotional turmoil still facing women trying to determine the direction of their lives since the Women's Movement has rendered such decisions so much more self-conscious. The narrator (possibly Atwood herself, who gave birth to a daughter in 1976) tells a story of a happily pregnant woman named Jeanie. And in one of Marian's dreams she says that her feet were dissolving like "melting jelly. Vol. Anthology: The New Oxford Book of Canadian Verse in English, 1982. Vol. What possible future does Marian see her representing? carrying food home in winter margaret atwood analysishow long does it take to digest raw broccoli. 9. Published in 1971, Atwood's poetry collection entitled Power Politics offers another study in the decay of a relationship amid the various miscommunications and misunderstandings that plague them. Two years after Friedan's book was published, Friedan helped start the National Organization of Women (NOW). Margaret Atwood. The title story explores Sallys excessive concern with her husband and lack of awareness of herself. Special Collections and University Archives, 301-405-9212 Copyright 1999 - 2023 GradeSaver LLC. If there are three dates, the first date is the date of the original Toronto, Ontario: ECW Press, 1998. Marshall, Tom, "Atwood Under and Above Water," in Harsh and Lovely Land: The Major Canadian Poets and the Making of a Canadian Tradition, University of British Columbia Press, 1979, pp. Snow in Carrying Food Home in Winter is a motif for forbidding, frosty weather. Kirk H. Beetz. Goldblatt, Patricia F., "Reconstructing Margaret Atwood's Protagonists," in World Literature Today, Vol. She frequently envisions the open, green spaces she will create, but she seems to have the same limitation as The City Planners in Atwoods poem of that name. Download the Forest Society Mobile App, powered by OuterSpatial, Forest Society North at The Rocks Campaign, Forest Society Celebrates Earth Day at Mt Major, Sophie Suggests: What to Read & Watch This Winter, Coming Soon to Creek Farm: A Better Visitor Experience. They begin to ask her out, curious as to the mysterious sources of her charm. Historical and Cultural Context Despite clever packaging, Marian becomes increasingly repulsed by the voracious animal appetite driving human consumption and its wanton exploitation of the planet's other living species. People are a problem: They ruin her aesthetically perfect designs, cluttering and littering the landscape. Though her readers already know Atwoods message, it bears repeating. 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Earn Points and Get Rewards. In Hairball, Kat, who is in her thirties, is betrayed by both a previously acquiescent lover and her own body. In Crow Song, the crow sings, I raised the banner/ which decreed Hope. The crow is positive about life notwithstanding the decomposition of corn and anticipates that human beings would regard the clarion call of positivity. Margaret Atwood was born on November 18, 1939, in Ottawa, Ontario, to parents of Nova Scotian origin. All rights reserved. 12. 12. Gale Cengage The longest entries discuss the novel Surfacing in relation to syntax and theme, particularly related to Amerindian influences and shamanism. It is therefore important not to lose sight of the human strength and tenacity (a favorite Atwood word) which also informs her work. Cameron, Elspeth, Famininity, or Parody of Autonomy: Anorexia Nervosa and The Edible Woman, Journal of Canadian Studies, Vol. She begins to feel and actually to be more attractive. 1995 eNotes.com What kind of prospective husband is Peter? Many of the short pieces here are explicitly about storytelling. What is the source of her indecision about her future? Ed. Kirk H. Beetz. 12. 2001 eNotes.com The last date is today's The predominant setting is Toronto, no longer the Good but now the polluted, the unsafe, the dingy, the dangerous, and, worst, the indifferent. The first and last stories in Bluebeards Egg reveal Atwood in an atypically mellow mood. The mystery of those questions provides the continuous undertow of dread in Atwood's story. Word Count: 591. in U.S. as Writing with Intent: Essays, Reviews, Personal Prose, 1983-2005, 2005); Waltzing Again: New and Selected Conversations with Margaret Atwood, 2006 (with others; Earl G. Ingersoll, editor). (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); The question of human warmth and life and where they are to be found is more acutely raised in Polarities, a strange, somewhat abstract story which also comments on the theme of alienation. And we also take comfort that the promise of spring is always somewhere on the horizon. 1984: The Canadian Royal Commission on Equality in Employment makes recommendations for sweeping changes in this area but later tables its report. Illinois UP, 1988. The Dark Voyage: The Edible Woman as Romance, in The Art of Margaret Atwood, 1981. Gale Cengage The first section of the novel brings the reader into the world of Gilead with little background or explanation. For many of these protagonists (as in Atwoods other works), language is a weapon of choice: In Uncles, Susanna, though emotionally unfulfilled, is a successful, ambitious journalist; in Hack Wednesday, Marcia is a freelance columnist; in Weight, the narrator and Molly, aggressive lawyers, play elaborate word games to ward off threatening realities; in The Bog Man, middle-aged Julie mythologizes her disastrous youthful affair with Connor. The Page explores the blank whiteness of an empty page and the myriad stories that lurk beneath it. 4, October, 1991, pp. The story is rich in comedy and in social satire, much of it directed against attitudes that make a person from another culture as alien as a man from Mars. Christines affluent parents think of themselves as liberal and progressive. Do you consider that a happy or an unhappy ending, given the context the novel provides for that ending? The daily chases of a bizarre, small, Asian man in hot pursuit of a rather large Christine (a mouse chasing an elephant, as Atwood describes it) attract the attention of other students and make Christine interesting to her male acquaintances for the first time. Food and Power: Homer, Carroll, Atwood, and Others. Mosaic 20 (Summer, 1987): 37-55. The overall theme of the poem, is the prison-like setting the landlady has created for herself. a place where she can suffer. We take care to make sure one of the most important days of your life is just like you've dreamed it would be. 1995 eNotes.com Eventually, through the overreactions and interventions of others, complaints are made to the police, and the inscrutable foreigner is deported, leaving Christine with mingled feelings of relief and regret. Gale Cengage May, Charles E., ed. Father pursues dozens of interests at once: botany, zoology, history, politics, carpentry, gardening. Sally is no longer complacent, no longer certain she wants to know what lies beneath the surface. Carbondale: The Edible Woman, the premier work of fiction by noted Canadian poet Margaret Atwood, is a forerunner of much of the feminist literature that would follow the theme of woman in search of. Analysis of Margaret Atwood's Novels By NASRULLAH MAMBROL on April 22, 2018 ( 2 ) For Atwood, an unabashed Canadian, literature became a means to cultural and personal self-awareness. 1 May 2023 , Last Updated on June 1, 2019, by eNotes Editorial. One piece discusses Atwoods transition from poetry to fiction; another is a feminist reading of her poetry. The theme of isolation and alienation recurs: There are borders and fences; generational gaps, which make parents and children strangers to each other; failed communication between women and men; gaps between language and felt experience. But she herself invites the author's satiric eye when her preoccupation leads to a self-destructive refusal to eat just about anything. If youve never hiked Mount Major, go early or try visiting on a weekday if you can. Why does eating play so prominent a role in consumer culture? If you want to earn extra Karma credit, bring a trash bag and help clean up what the oblivious left behindthats often what students do on school field trips to Mount Major. It is toward restoration of balance in her view of herself as an organism in a competitive universe that the narrative moves her. Accepting her own complicity in being a victim by allowing others to dictate her actions, Marian, ceremoniously and appropriately, bakes a sponge cake shaped like a woman and dressed as she was dressed for the party at Peters. No. When does the first person "I" surface, and when does it disappear? 105, March, 1997, pp. Word Count: 46. GradeSaver, 19 February 2020 Web. Atwood, Margaret, Great Unexpectations: An Autobiographical Foreword, Margaret Atwood: Visions and Forms. Trusting the Untrustworthy, in Journal of Canadian Fiction. At the storys conclusion, she seems lost, now past either hope or love, retreating into the unreal but safe world of John Galsworthy and Anthony Trollope. Vol. Ann also is studying urban design because she has fantasies of rearranging Toronto. Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. In the fourth paragraph, Atwood refers to the German folk tale 'God's Food'. tags: freedom. The battle between the sexes is again the focus of most of the ten stories, the combatants ranging from youth through middle age. ", "The Edible Woman - Literary Style" Novels for Students eNotes.com, Inc. It seems that the encounter with the alien is the most interesting or significant thing that has ever happened to Christine and that her only feeling of human relationship is for a person with whom she had no real relationship. eNotes.com (Delivery is Temporarily Unavailable). But by putting such analysis into the mouth of the pedantic Fish she exposes the political uses of literary criticism wherein many a female story falls prey to male appropriation and distortion. Carrying Food Home in Winter. Her work is seen simply as the fulfillment of her wifely duties. 49, February 1970, p. 267. 1984: The percentage of poor, single-mother families rises to 62 percent. 103-11. Our imaginations are drawn strongly towards the dark and cold of winter, even while we may dread the reality. 2. 73, Spring 1999, p. 275. 9-19. In New Hampshire, most people are willing to follow the Carry in-Carry out guideline. In her inner world is Ed, like a doll within a Russian wooden doll and in Ed is Eds inner world, which she cant get at. The more she speculates about Eds inner world, the more perplexed she becomes. Finally, she decides that people such as Mrs. Nolan, Mrs. Nolans unruly children, and the entire collection of exotics who live in the boardinghouse will have to be excluded from urban utopia by a high wire fence. First Appearances collection, 0007-LIT-RARE. Kirk H. Beetz. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. All their lives, his identity was ephemeral and undefined, but as Jane recalls his slow decline and death of an unnamed disease and ponders his enigmatic nature, the television offers the 150-years-dead Torrington, emerging virtually intact from his icy grave to speak eloquently to the living. No. Recalling herself as a university student, she feels as though she has become as unfathomable to her mother as a visitor from outer space, a timetraveler come back from the future, bearing news of a great disaster. There are distances too great for maternal love to cross. The absence of the yellow bowl is causing you more pain than hunger.

Sims 4: Fnaf Sister Location Cc, Quel Est Le Salaire D'un Consul Honoraire ?, Articles C

This entry was posted in check personalized plate availability michigan. Bookmark the gchq manchester apprenticeship.

carrying food home in winter margaret atwood analysis

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. brooklyn tabernacle pastor.